So You Think You Can Dance Vs. American Idol

So You Think You Can Dance (Season 5) rocks! The show is just oozing with skill and talent. Dancers for season 5 were such good dancers that it made the show really hit the top. What makes me love the show more are the judges... they're truly adorable! They have wit, a great sense of humor, technical know-how... and I feel as though most of what they say has a lot of meat in it. I can't say the same for American Idol though. And Ellen to be the 4th judge on the next season of AI...? What the...? She's a host and knows very well how to talk... but judging on American Idol? Where have all the star singers gone?!